All articlesGuide

Why doesn't a glass of wine cost the same price in the United States and Europe?

4 min read

In Paris, a glass of Sancerre with a buttered baguette costs eleven euros. In Barcelona, some tapas bars serve wine for two euros fifty. In New York, this same casual gesture can easily exceed twenty dollars. How to explain such a gap, and what does it really reveal about the way wine reaches our glasses?

What travelers say (without making it a statistic)

Enthusiasts often compare, after a trip, the price of a glass drunk in Europe and the one charged in the United States for an experience perceived as similar. These impressions do not constitute statistics: the contexts, wines and establishments vary too much for the comparison to really hold up. But they point to a structural reality that industry professionals have been describing for a long time.

In an article from Grub Street published on September 3, 2024, Pascaline Lepeltier, a sommelier trained in France and Belgium and now director of beverages at Chambers in Tribeca, states it clearly: the constraints on how one can obtain wine, where one can buy it and how one can buy it are far more complex in the United States than in Europe. The report also describes the three-tier system born after Prohibition — producer, distributor, retailer or restaurant — a wholesale margin of approximately thirty percent on average, and the frequent practice that sets the price of a glass at the equivalent of the cost of buying the entire bottle. Gabriella Borg Costanzi, director of service and wines at Le Crocodile in Williamsburg, explains that she proceeds differently: rather than dividing the bottle price by five theoretical glasses, she accounts for losses, the duration of the wine being open and the risk of deterioration — particularly for wines fermented on indigenous yeasts. A glass of Chardonnay from Sta. Rita Hills is listed there at twenty-one dollars, which she herself describes as a reasonable price given her real constraints. Sashi Moorman, co-founder of Sandhi Wines, recalls that most American wineries work with some form of debt, which weighs on the acceptable minimum selling price, not to mention the cost of labor in California — minimum wage of sixteen dollars an hour, overtime, manual harvesting for organically farmed vineyards.

Behind the bill: distribution and margins

The price difference is not explained solely by inflation or the standing of the establishment. It is largely due to this architecture of the American alcohol market. In France, a producer can sell directly to a restaurant or a wine shop, bypassing part of the chain.

Jason Haas (Tablas Creek), in a blog post dated February 16, 2009, describes the concrete mechanism: a bottle sold for twenty-five dollars at retail leaves approximately ten dollars to the producer, after distributors and agents have taken their successive margins. This scheme is nearly eighteen years old, but the basic logic of the multi-tier circuit remains a useful reference point. In his example, a glass could be priced around the cost of the bottle purchased by the restaurant; Haas also noted that the markup per glass could reach four hundred percent, which mechanically implies only being able to offer by the glass wines purchased at moderate prices. On the menu, a restaurant that resells a bottle at triple its purchase cost follows a fairly standard rule — it is not necessarily abusive if the service and storage are up to par.

One glass does not equal another glass

Comparing two by-the-glass prices only makes sense if you specify the wine, the location, the purchase circuit and the volume served. The type of wine changes everything: a house table wine does not follow the same cost logic as an appellation wine. And the supply circuit — direct purchase from the producer, regional trade, national importer — influences the starting price before the restaurant even sets its margin.

The perceived gap is real, but it is not uniform. A New York restaurant can offer a glass for fifteen dollars, another for thirty for a similar wine. In Europe, by-the-glass prices in a Paris or Milan wine bar can also be surprising depending on the choice and neighborhood.

How to read a wine list without getting ripped off

A few simple reflexes make it easier to navigate, regardless of which country you are in.

Ask for the volume of the glass if it is not specified on the menu: a difference in serving size changes the value-for-money ratio significantly.

Note whether the menu offers both by-the-glass and by-the-bottle wines for the same references. By comparing the two prices, you immediately perceive the markup logic applied by the establishment.

Compare the bottle price to what a local wine shop offers for the same wine.

Beware of by-the-glass wines that are too cheap in upscale establishments: an unusually low price can mean a bottle that has been open too long or a standardized wine chosen solely for its margin.

These reference points do not make the wine list transparent all at once, but they help get out of the diffuse impression of being poorly informed — which is, after all, the best position from which to choose with pleasure.

Get new articles by email

One email when an article is published, nothing else.

Double opt-in by email. One-click unsubscribe. No ads.